Smart Locks vs. Traditional Locks: Which Is Better for Your Business?

Keys are simple until someone loses one. Here's how smart locks compare to traditional locks for a business, and when each one makes sense.

2 min read
Keypad smart lock on an office door next to a ring of traditional metal keys

An employee quits. Did they hand back their key? Did they make a copy?

With a traditional lock, you can't know for sure. With a smart lock, you delete their code and move on.

But smart isn't always the answer. Here's how to choose.

The Case for Traditional Locks

  • No batteries, no Wi-Fi. They just work.
  • Lower upfront cost.
  • Simple. Nothing to set up or update.

The catch: keys get lost, copied and kept. Every time that happens, you rekey or replace. And you never know who opened the door, or when.

The Case for Smart Locks

  • Codes instead of keys. Give each person their own and delete it in seconds.
  • Temporary access. Cleaners, contractors and deliveries get codes that only work when you want.
  • Remote control. Lock or unlock from your phone, depending on the model.
  • Fits your system. Z-Wave models connect to alarm and smart building platforms.

The catch: batteries need changing, and setup takes a few minutes more.

Which Smart Lock Fits?

For Z-Wave systems (alarm panels and smart hubs), the Kwikset Home Connect 620 is a keypad deadbolt with Z-Wave Long Range, and the Yale YRD634 is a Z-Wave keypad lock.

For interior office doors that use a handle, the Kwikset SmartCode 912 lever brings keypad entry to a lever lock.

For Wi-Fi without a hub, the Kwikset Halo Select is a touchscreen smart lock with Wi-Fi and Matter.

When You Need More Than a Smart Lock

Smart locks are great for a handful of doors. Once you're managing many doors, many people or strict schedules, step up to a full access control system with card readers, controllers and electric hardware like an HES 5200C electric strike or an ADI Pro 600 lb maglock.

The Quick Verdict

  • 1 to 2 doors, few people: traditional or a smart lock
  • Staff changes, cleaners, contractors: smart lock
  • Many doors, schedules, audit trails: access control

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if a smart lock's battery dies?

Most give low-battery warnings well in advance, and many keypad models still include a physical key as a backup. Check the specific model.

Are smart locks secure enough for a business?

They remove the biggest risk of keys, which is copies you don't know about. For high-security or many-door sites, a full access control system adds more control.

What's Z-Wave?

A wireless standard used by many alarm panels and smart hubs. A Z-Wave lock can be controlled and monitored through that system.

Can I give someone access for just one day?

With many smart locks, yes. You can create temporary or scheduled codes, depending on the lock and the app or system it connects to.

Upgrade Your Doors

Browse our access control and locks, or request a quote and we'll recommend the right lock for every door.

← All articles
Access ControlBusiness SecuritySmart Locks